Review of One Piece: Episode of Alabasta

onepiecemovie8

One Piece: Episode of Alabasta is the eighth animated movie based on Eiichiro Oda’s popular manga series. The film sees rubber man Luffy journey to the desert kingdom of Alabasta, which is presently suffering from a mysterious drought. As always Luffy is joined by his crew of Straw Hat pirates whose roster includes a shape shifting reindeer, a flirtatious chef who literally kicks ass and a bandana wearing blade master who fights with a sword lodged between his teeth. This eighth feature film sees the Straw Hats tackle a nasty chap named Crocodile who is plotting to plunge the region into civil war. Hurry up Luffy! Defeat Crocodile and make it “snappy.”

OVERVIEW

If the above-mentioned synopsis sounds familiar it should because Episode of Alabasta is a retelling of the Alabasta story arc, which has previously been covered in the One Piece anime series. It’s disappointing to see the animators squander a movie budget on re-treading old ground and the decision is all the more perplexing when you realize that the Alabasta saga ran for almost forty episodes. Condensing so much material into a ninety-minute flick simply doesn’t work, with the end result feeling like a disjointed series of clips. Although the filler saturated One Piece series could certainly benefit from the services of a good editor, exorcising so much content is going from one extreme to another.

Things get hilariously bad when characters that have previously not been introduced randomly appear onscreen. One such example has the Straw Hats travelling across Alabasta’s sandy dunes atop a gigantic crab. The oversized crustacean is lending them aid as he is the acquaintance of a camel that is travelling with the group. Who is this camel I speak of? He’s a comic relief character that featured in the series, but up till that point he was completely absent from the movie adaptation. Anyone watching the film with no prior knowledge of the source material will be left scratching their heads… if they weren’t already at the prospect of how a desert animal and sea creature could be friends.

Perhaps the biggest travesty of all is that the show’s exciting action has been butchered in order to squeeze the narrative into a ninety-minute feature. For me, the highlight of the Alabasta story was seeing the Straw Hats take on Crocodile’s henchmen. Each of the antagonist’s lackeys has a special ability that the heroes have to overcome. It was cool seeing the good guys suss out their opponents’ weaknesses in order to turn the tide of battle. Alas most of that is missing from this movie as the action scenes jump straight into the middle of a fight. We see the Straw Hats battered and bruised, with no idea of how they sustained their injuries, before another time skip takes us to the end of the duel. It’s more anticlimactic than a WWE pay per view.

VERDICT

My rating for One Piece: Episode of Alabasta is a one out of five. I honestly have no idea why this movie exists. Who is the target audience for this film? One Piece fans would surely prefer to re-watch the series over settling for this abridged flop. Perhaps the idea was to give viewers unfamiliar with One Piece the opportunity to dip their toes with something that isn’t a huge time sink? If so Episode of Alabasta fails because the choppy storytelling will leave anyone unacquainted with the franchise totally confused. There’s little to recommend here unless you like watching Luffy yell terrible dialogue at a Sandman clone. Don’t bother buying this Blu Ray. If you really must watch this movie then (Straw Hat) pirate it instead.

13 thoughts on “Review of One Piece: Episode of Alabasta

  1. I don’t watch One Piece, but I get the impression this film was released simply because they could. It’s a pity a lot of anime films seem to get this sort of treatment, I think it puts other studios off making anime films if they don’t see them as being a proper medium.

  2. I remember the Alabasta arc having so many characters and a lot of moving parts. No matter how hard I try, I can’t think of way to fit all that in a feature film’s runtime and still come out with anything that makes sense. I agree, I have no idea why they’d even produce something like this. It’s not like those episodes of One Piece are hard to get through other means.

  3. I’m not sure I get the point of condensing story arcs into movies. What about the one introducing Chopper, Episode of Chopper Plus, that arc? Everyone does love Chopper. I recall having Franky there was weird, introducing characters out of order. The animation style was unique. Episode of Alabasta doesn’t even compare to that.

    Although, most of the movies haven’t been that good. I did like Baron Omasturi, but other than that only the more canonical films directed by Oda — Strong World and Z — are worth it at all.

    It’s just too big a franchise, and it must be milked, with all these movies coming out every year.

  4. Could it be that they tried to adapt the much shorter Manga version but tried to keep it familiar for those that saw the anime, the result being this mess?

  5. This is the worst localized One Piece film. I couldn’t even finish it and I’m pretty much obsessed with the series and everything around it. Strong World and Film Z were great – I’m going to see Film GOLD at the movies tomorrow night- are you planning to go to a theater showing, or wait for video? I’m kind of pumped to see a One Piece movie with a theater full of fans – it was a great experience for DBZ: Resurrection F.

      • That sounds like my hometown, where I live now we have 3 or 4 large theaters and still don’t get MOST of them, it seems like someone or some group has to request them. Film GOLD was great though – based on your interests, and outside of my bias – I can say you’d probably dig it. Check it out when it’s on streaming or video sometime in the future =)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s